The Advertising Standards Committee considered consumer complaints
against a Teazers radio commercial. The commercial states “Men,
if you think that the only reason to come to Teazers cabaret
bar is to see drop dead gorgeous butt naked women, consider this:
Candy dances to pay her way through varsity; Derby dances to
pay her young brother’s school fees; Lap dancer, Brandy
is saving for vital breast reduction surgery … So come
to Teazers and help these girls’ dreams come true. Please,
it’s the right this to do. But do yourself a favour and
get here before Brandy has the op.”
Complaints
In essence, the complainants object to the commercial as they
believe that it promotes an immoral activity. The complainants
contend that this business exploits the women in its employ and
is immoral. They further contend that the statement “get
here before Brandy has the op” is degrading to women. The
complainants state that in this day and age when society is trying
to reduce violence against women and increase respect and love
for them, places like Teazers are inappropriate. The broadcasting
of such advertisements is allowing these places to promote themselves
and thereby promote violence and disrespect to women.
Response
The respondent contends that since the first flighting of the
commercial the complaints submitted are the first ones to have
been received. The respondent states that the commercial at issue
has found favour amongst a wide audience (e.g. it won a gold
Loerie award; voted as the most popular radio commercial).
At the meeting the respondent submitted that the complainants
appear not to be objecting to the content of the advertisement,
but that the complainants have a moral problem with the type
of business that is advertised. The respondent also stated that
it is its not aware of any laws that prohibit places like Teazers
from promoting themselves. The respondent contended that although
the advertisement deals with a controversial subject, the execution
deals with it responsibly.
Co-option
Two officials from the Commission on Gender Equality were co-opted
to assist the Committee in its deliberation on the matter. The
Commission stated that its opinion on the matter is based on
the whole activity of the respondent. It also acknowledged that
the merits of the activity cannot be considered by the Advertising
Standards Committee in that women who participate in these activities
are exercising their freedom of choice and that there is no law
which presently prohibits the existence of cabaret bars such
as Teazers. However, the Commission stated that the radio commercial
portrays women as sex objects and in a degrading manner.
Advertising
Standards Committee Ruling
The Committee is not aware of any law that prohibits the existence
of a strip tease club and therefore the ASA cannot consider and
rule on the morality of the respondent’s activities. The
Committee can only deal with the matter insofar as it relates
to the content of advertising.
The target market for the commercial is adult males. The flighting
of the radio commercial at issue should take into consideration
the sensitivities and credulity of certain members of the society,
such as children or young people. It would appear that the radio
commercial at issue is insensitively flighted during family time.
The respondent must be sensitive regarding media placement and
time placement of the advertisement at issue.
Where the commercial is insensitively and irresponsibly flighted
during family time, it is likely to offend the susceptibilities
of consumers and thus would be in breach of several codes.
In view of the above contraventions the commercial must be flighted
at appropriate times and in appropriate media in accordance with
this ruling with immediate effect, material deadlines permitting.
|